Levels were close to regulatory limit
The maximum permissible level of glyphosate in soy in the EU was raised dramatically after GM soy was first introduced (by 200 times in 1999).
1. Nestle steps up testing after weedkiller found in coffee beans
2. US NGOs target Twinings and Beech-Nut over glyphosate and pesticide contamination of 'natural' products
---
1. Nestle steps up testing after weedkiller found in coffee beans
Sustainable Pulse, Sep 27 2019
https://sustainablepulse.com/2019/09/27/nestle-steps-up-testing-after-weedkiller-found-in-coffee-beans/
Nestle SA is increasing checks on the coffee it buys, after recent tests showed beans from some countries had levels of the weedkiller glyphosate that are close to a regulatory limit, Bloomberg reported Thursday.
The world's largest coffee roaster has informed suppliers of Indonesian and certain Brazilian beans of the new procedures, which go into effect starting Oct. 1, according to memos seen by Bloomberg. The company says the new measures "should be temporary" until producing countries correct the application of glyphosate.
The move comes at a time when many countries have either banned or are seeking to prohibit the use of glyphosate, used in the Roundup weedkiller. Bayer AG, which spent $63 billion buying the product's maker, Monsanto, is now facing billions of dollars worth of lawsuits claiming it causes cancer.
"We actively monitor chemical residues, including glyphosate, in the green coffee that we purchase," Switzerland-based Nestle said in a statement. "This monitoring program has shown that in some green coffee lots chemical residue levels are close to limits defined by regulations. We are reinforcing our controls working with suppliers to ensure that our green coffee continues to meet regulations all around the world."
The new measures have the potential to complicate global coffee trade-flows. The additional testing requirement is mostly for beans being shipped to factories in Europe, Australia and Malaysia, where legal limits on glyphosate are stricter than most other countries. The Brazilian memo was directed to suppliers of conilon, as the nation's more bitter robusta beans are known.
Brazilian beans already faced restrictions from buyers who need to meet Europe's glyphosate limits, said Edimilson Calegari, general manager for Cooabriel, Brazil's largest robusta-coffee cooperative. "We are working with our members to reduce the use to meet Europe requirements, which is much stricter than most other countries, including the U.S."
Nestle said it's working with growers to reduce the need for glyphosate. "Our agronomists will continue to work with coffee farmers to help them improve their weed management practices, including the appropriate use of herbicides and adoption of other weeding methods."
---
2. US NGOs target Twinings and Beech-Nut over glyphosate and pesticide contamination of 'natural' products
Sustainable Pulse, Jul 22 2019
https://sustainablepulse.com/2019/07/22/us-ngos-target-twinings-and-beech-nut-over-glyphosate-and-pesticide-contamination-of-natural-products/
The Children's Health Defense (CHD) and the Organic Consumers Association (OCA) have recently announced two separate lawsuits targeting Beech-Nut and Twinings over pesticide contamination of their 'natural' products.
Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., Chairman and Chief Legal Counsel for CHD announced a lawsuit on July 9 against Beech-Nut Nutrition Company.
The complaint, filed in Washington, DC, asserts that Beech-Nut's material misrepresentations and omissions violate the District of Columbia Consumer Protection Procedures Act. The complaint states that Beech-Nut's "labeling and marketing of the Products deceives parents who seek to be mindful of what is contained in the baby foods they provide to their infants." "The Plaintiff, Children's Health Defense, brings this unlawful trade practices case on behalf of itself, its members, and the general public, seeking relief including an injunction to stop the deceptive marketing and sale of the Products."
Tests conducted by independent laboratories using liquid chromatography mass spectrometry have revealed that the varieties of Beech-Nut Naturals products purchased by CHD contain residues of multiple synthetic pesticides and namely acetamiprid, captan, and/or glyphosate. These varieties include: "Just Apples," "Apples, Cinnamon & Granola," "Apple & Pumpkin," and "Just Mango, Apple & Avocado."
None of the pesticides are "natural" substances and Beech-Nut claims that the products that were tested are "100% natural". Acetamiprid is a neonicotinoid synthetic insecticide, Captan is a synthetic chloroalkyl thio fungicide and Glyphosate is the world's most used herbicide.
Meanwhile on the same day, the OCA sued Twinings North America, Inc. and its parent company, Associated British Foods PLC, for the deceptive labeling, marketing and sale of Twinings Tea of London products. The suit was filed on behalf of OCA by Richman Law Group, in D.C. Superior Court under the D.C. Consumer Protection Procedures Act.
"No reasonable consumer who reads the words 'pure' and '100% natural ingredients,' whether on Twinings' packaging or in other advertising or marketing communications, such as the company's website, would expect those products to contain residues of glyphosate, a synthetic herbicide, and unnatural insecticides," said Ronnie Cummins, OCA co-founder and
international director.
"Consumer surveys consistently bear out the fact that health-conscious shoppers rely on labels and online research to make buying decisions. Twinings should have to clean up its supply chain so that its products are in fact 'pure' and '100% natural,' or be forced to stop making those claims," Cummins said.
The suit specifically calls out Twinings Green Tea, and Green Tea with Mint, products.
Tests conducted by an independent laboratory using liquid chromatography mass spectrometry revealed the amount of glyphosate levels in the Twinings Tea samples to be up to 0.332 milligrams per kilogram. The exact source of the glyphosate residue in the samples is known only to Twinings and its suppliers, according to the suit.
Testing also revealed residues of two synthetic insecticides: thiacloprid, a neonicotinoid; and bifenthrin, a pyrethroid. Both chemicals are known neurotoxins.
The suit alleges that by deceiving consumers about the nature, quality and/or ingredients of its products, Twinings is able to sell a greater volume of products, to charge higher prices for the products, and to take away market share from competing products, thereby increasing its own sales and profits.
The suits are the latest in a growing list of actions by NGOs against brands that label their products as 'natural' but contain non-natural substances.