GM Watch
  • Main Menu
    • Home
    • News
      • Latest News
      • Newsletter subscription
      • Daily Digest
      • News Reviews
      • News Languages
    • Articles
      • GM Myth Makers
      • GM Reports
      • GM Quotes
      • GM Myths
      • Non-GM successes
      • GM Firms
        • Monsanto: a history
        • Monsanto: resources
        • Bayer: a history
        • Bayer: resources
    • Videos
      • Latest Videos
      • Must see videos
      • Cornell videos
      • Agriculture videos
      • Labeling videos
      • Animals videos
      • Corporations videos
      • Corporate takeover videos
      • Contamination videos
      • Latin America videos
      • India videos
      • Asia videos
      • Food safety videos
      • Songs videos
      • Protests videos
      • Biofuel myths videos
      • Index of GM crops and foods
      • Index of speakers
      • Health Effects
    • Contact
    • About
    • Links
    • Donations
    • How donations will help us
News and comment on genetically modified foods and their associated pesticides    
  • News
    • Latest News
    • Newsletter subscription
    • News Reviews
    • News Languages
      • Notícias em Português
      • Nieuws in het Nederlands
      • Nachrichten in Deutsch
    • Archive
      • 2021 articles
      • 2020 articles
      • 2019 articles
      • 2018 articles
      • 2017 articles
      • 2016 articles
      • 2015 articles
      • 2014 articles
      • 2013 articles
      • 2012 articles
      • 2011 articles
      • 2010 articles
      • 2009 articles
      • 2008 articles
      • 2007 articles
      • 2006 articles
      • 2005 articles
      • 2004 articles
      • 2003 articles
      • 2002 articles
      • 2001 articles
      • 2000 articles
  • Articles
    • GM Myth Makers
    • GM Reports
    • How donations will help us
    • GM Quotes
    • GM Myths
    • Non-GM successes
    • GM Firms
      • Monsanto: a history
      • Monsanto: resources
      • Bayer: a history
      • Bayer: resources
  • Videos
    • Index of speakers
    • Glyphosate Videos
    • Latest Videos
    • Must see videos
    • Health Effects
    • Cornell videos
    • Agriculture videos
    • Labeling videos
    • Animals videos
    • Corporations videos
    • Corporate takeover videos
    • Contamination videos
    • Latin America videos
    • India videos
    • Asia videos
    • Food safety videos
    • Songs videos
    • Protests videos
    • Biofuel myths videos
    • Index of GM crops and foods
  • Contact
  • About
  • Links
  • Donations
  • 2021
  • 2021a

LATEST NEWS

  • No sooner had Brexit been approved, than the GMO lobby shifted up a few gears

  • "No one wants GM food – but Westminster wants to foist it upon Scotland anyway"

  • Daszak facing calls to step down from Covid-19 inquiries as WHO team arrives in Wuhan

  • US FDA won't transfer animal gene-editing authority to USDA

  • The lab-leak hypothesis and a "gamechanging" article

GMWatch Facebook cornfield banner

SCIENCE SUPPORTS REGULATION OF GENE EDITING

Plant tissue cultures

GENE EDITING: UNEXPECTED OUTCOMES AND RISKS

Damaged DNA on fire

GENE-EDITED CROPS & FOODS

Help stop the new threat

LATEST VIDEOS

  • Seed keepers and truth tellers: From the frontlines of GM agriculture
  • Myths and Truths of Gene-Edited Foods
  • Dangers of gene-edited foods

News Menu

  • Latest News
  • News Reviews
  • Archive
  • Languages

Please support GMWatch

Donations

You can donate via Paypal or credit/debit card.

Some of you have opted to give a regular donation. This is greatly appreciated as it helps place us on a more stable financial basis. Thank you for your support!

Monsanto’s new GM tech to defeat corn rootworm “will work only briefly” – Scientific American

Details
Published: 08 March 2017
Twitter

Corn Rootworm - Diabrotica virgifera virgifera larvae

Europe proves that crop diversity and rotation – not GM – are the ways to combat the pest

The most costly beetle in the US, the corn rootworm, keeps evolving ways to resist pesticides designed to protect a $50-billion corn industry, reports an important article in Scientific American (behind a paywall).

The latest attempt, from Monsanto, involves a genetic engineering technique that embeds gene-silencing (RNA interference or RNAi for short) molecules in corn that target specific rootworm genes, killing the insect.

Safety questions

Monsanto claims the technology is pest-specific and safe for non-target organisms. But the article quotes Martha Crouch of the Center for Food Safety as saying that RNAi technology is a perfect example of the “chaos of an emerging technology” that seems to promise only progress, until “the oops moment when something unexpected and harmful” happens — such as ozone holes, carcinogenic children's pyjamas, and rat-sized-rootworms.

The article points out that the safety question is far from settled. In a 2012 paper, a Chinese research team reported that it found snippets of RNA from food plants in the livers of mice that consumed those plants. The RNA affected a cholesterol-regulating gene also found in humans. This “cross-kingdom effect” was surprising because these types of RNA were not thought to survive in the hostile environment of the mammalian gut; if true, the results raised the possibility that RNAi in plants could affect humans. The article adds that a study presented at a conference in 2013 found that RNA created to kill rootworms could also kill ladybugs, a beloved beneficial insect.

Pests will quickly evolve resistance

Some experts argue that these studies do not suggest a health risk to humans – but quite apart from that concern, the article says scientists believe the new RNAi technology will in any case work only briefly before pests evolve resistance. The entomologist Joseph Spencer is quoted as saying, “It's a lesson that we have failed to learn over and over and over. “Natural selection is always going to win.”

And this attempted techno-fix misses the real problem, says the article – the giant, single-crop farms that give the pests chances to adapt and survive: “The rootworm thrives on predictability. Monoculture makes it easy for a lone grower to farm 2,000 acres. But it also makes it easy for the rootworm to destroy those acres.”

As Spencer says, “We gave it a wonderful life.”

Europe shows crop diversity is best defence

The article reports that things are very different in Europe, where the insect turned up in the early 1990s and where GMOs are barely cultivated. European farmers feared the same levels of devastation seen in the US. But it didn’t happen because “Europe has smaller farms, whose operators plant less corn and rotate it with a wider variety of plants. The insect does some damage in regions where farmers plant corn continuously, but overall populations remain under control.”

Researcher Stefan Vidal of the University of Göttingen in Germany, who helped to coordinate the European Union–funded response to the rootworm invasion, says, “The rootworm is not a problem in Europe.” Diversity, European farmers concluded, is the best defence.

Overall, it’s refreshing to see Scientific American publish an article that predicts – surely accurately – the failure of a GM technology based on known evolutionary mechanisms.

Menu

Home

News

News Archive

News Reviews

Videos

Articles

GM Myth Makers

GM Reports

GM Myths

GM Quotes

How Donations Will Help Us

Contacts

Contact Us

About

Facebook

Twitter

RSS

Content 1999 - 2021 GMWatch.
Web Development By SCS Web Design