1.Bt Brinjal May Sneak Into India If Nod Denied
2.The chaos called Bt brinjal!
In Medhasan village of North Gujarat many farmers are complaining that Maharashtra Hybrid Seed Company [Mahyco - Monsanto's partner in India], a big-time promoter of the hybrid seeds, has provided some of them Bt brinjal seeds to 'try out' in their fields. (item 2)
"The Indian authorities should permit commercialisation of transgenic brinjal before this (brinjal) makes illegal entry into our farms and markets," said Dr Shanthu Shantharam [a former Syngenta employee and GM lobbyist whose advice has frequently been relied upon by the Indian Government: http://bit.ly/bwnqxp] (item 1)
NOTE: This looks very much like blackmail, or colonisation by contamination: "You're going to have Bt brinjal anyway, whether you like it or not, so you'd better make it official so you appear in control." Incidentally, we're told by someone who caught a TV report on the public hearing on Bt brinjal in Andhra Pradesh, that a farmer was quoted as saying he was also already growing Bt brinjal - Mahyco-Monsanto's patented crop for which there is no current regulatory approval.
1.Bt Brinjal May Sneak Into India If Nod Denied
Economic Times, Jan 28 2010
INDIAN agri-biotechnologists have warned that transgenic or genetically-modified brinjal could enter the Indian market illegally if the Union government refuses permission or delays commercialisation of the transgenic varieties of this key horticulture crop. Last October, the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) approved the commercialisation of transgenic brinjal in the country subject to the final nod from the Union Environment & Forest Ministry. The ministry has currently organised a series of public hearing campaigns to elicit views from various stake-holders on commercialising transgenic brinjal.
"We have several instances of how transgenic crops under field trials or being tested in labs have found their way to farmer fields even before they are formally approved and commercialised. The Indian authorities should permit commercialisation of transgenic brinjal before this (brinjal) makes illegal entry into our farms and markets," said Dr Shanthu Shantharam, a former transgenic crop regulator who had earlier served as branch head of Biotechnology Regulatory Services of the US Dept of Agriculture(USDA). There is some precedent to this. There have been instances of farmers growing transgenic cotton much before it was legally permitted. And experts say that illegal cultivation in India is quite common in case of hybrid varieties.
Globally too, there have been several instances of illegal cultivation of transgenic crops. Brazil was forced to permit the transgenic variety of soyabean once farmers began illegally cultivating it. Illegal cultivation of the crop continued in that country despite a court ruling banning such an activity. More recently, transgenic papaya which has been only approved in the US (in Hawaii) has already found its way to farms in Vietnam and Philippines, two countries which have not yet approved of this variety. "Transgenic varieties help to reduce the usage of pesticides something which would be of immense use for the small farmer in the country. Estimates indicate that brinjal farmers spend as much as Rs 6,000 per acre on pesticides, a figure which can drop by 40% to 50% if we permit transgenic brinjal. Field trials of transgenic brinjal have already indicated the crop's bio-safety,” said Dr TM Manjunath, a leading agri-biotechnologist and the former head of Monsanto's research centre in Bangalore.
According to Dr Kameswara Rao, founder of the Foundation for Biotechnology Awareness & Education (FBAE) the acreage under transgenic crops worldwide has risen from 1.7 million hectares in 1996 to 125 million hectares in 2008. While three Indian agenices have already developed transgenic brinjal varieties, field trials on brinjal or egg-plant are underway in Bangladesh and Philippines.
2.The chaos called Bt brinjal!
Sheela Bhatt in Ahmedabad
Rediff, February 2 2010
In Medhasan village of North Gujarat many farmers are complaining that Maharashtra Hybrid Seed Company (Mahyco), a big-time promoter of the hybrid seeds, has provided some of them Bt brinjal seeds to 'try out' in their fields.
Even though such reports have not been verified by any authority in Gujarat yet, farmers who are against the introduction of Bt brinjal express the fear that sooner than later some cultivators in Gujarat might start producing illegal Bt brinjal crop, just like they had done some years back in case of Bt cotton.
Bt brinjal is a genetically modified strain created by India's number one seeds company Mahyco in collaboration with American multinational Monsanto. The companies claim that these seeds improve yields and help the agriculture sector. Bt brinjal is created by modifying its gene with the help of agro-engineering so that it can resist certain insects/pests that create havoc in the fields.
The seeds of Bt brinjal (bacillus thuringiensis brinjal) are being developed in India by Mahyco and American multinational Monsanto. Monsanto, which has invested millions of dollars in research on GM strains, is now eyeing the Indian market for their GM seeds. Mahyco-Monsanto Biotech India had also enjoyed a monopoly in the supply of Bt cotton seeds.
Ramanbhai Patel, an agro-products expert and a respected farmer from Modasa in Gujarat, while speaking to rediff.com, claims: "We will be doomed if our farmers are lured by Mahyco to accept Bt brinjal seeds. How can you sow something whose side-effects are not yet known to anyone?"
Currently, a national debate is raging on the pluses and minuses of allowing production and marketing of Bt brinjal in India.
The Genetic Engineering Approval Committee has for the first time approved the trials and, eventually, the marketing of Bt brinjal in India. The government is in the process of taking a final call on the issue.
Non-governmental organisations and alert farmers are horrified at the GEAC's decision which is considered to be the first major step toward liberally allowing genetically modified crops and vegetables into the Indian market. Although Bt cotton is still produced in many Indian states, so far India has resisted the private sector's attempts to produce/market GM foods.
Gujarati farmers have made millions from Bt cotton in the last five years, but on the issue of Bt brinjal Indian farmers, including those in Gujarat, are divided.
The issue is so serious that India's renowned agriculture scientist M S Swaminathan has also urged the government to 'go slow' on it. Recently, he was quoted by a Chennai daily as saying: "Every technology has its benefits and risks. But it all depends on our capacity to analyse risks and benefits. We must analyse whether the risks are more or the benefits are more. There should be an authority to analyse these risks and benefits in a transparent way. Unfortunately, we don't have an authority like that."
Kapil Shah, head of the Baroda-based Jatan (an organisation that has been pioneering the organic farming movement in Gujarat), says: "The opposition to Bt brinjal is mainly because India doesn't have enough research facilities and infrastructure to monitor the long-term impact of GM foods. Companies that want to make millions from selling genetically engineered foods are the only ones doing any field research. There is no independent research or monitoring whatsoever." Shah is known for his significant research on natural and organic farming.
The opposition to Bt brinjal is so strong that Union Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh is touring the entire country and holding open sessions to understand firsthand the views of farmers and experts on the issue.
Ramanbhai Patel, who is a strong opponent of Bt brinjal, says: "What you wear on your skin (Bt cotton) is different from what you eat (Bt brinjal). How can you eat toxic food? The element that kills insects remains in the final product of GM brinjal. It is as simple as that."
Jatan's Shah says, "Wherever minister Ramesh has gone, most people have opposed Bt brinjal. Mahyco has sent its representatives to speak with cultivators but most of the farmers understand that they don't want to poison their land and their food."
According to Shah, the meetings called by Jairam Ramesh in Kolkata saw that of the 56 representations received, 41 opposed Bt brinjal. In Bhubaneswar, 65 of the 70 farmers and experts gathered there opposed Bt brinjal, while in Ahmedabad out of the 66 people who came to give their opinion at the open session, 51 opposed it.
"Ramesh is facing the ire of experts and farmers because they fear that the GM seed companies will enter the Indian market, by hook or crook," says Narsibhai Patel, who observed a token fast on January 30 at the Gandhi Ashram in Ahmedabad to oppose Bt brinjal.
He says, "Farmers won't pick up Bt brinjal seeds, like they took Bt cotton, because even when the production of brinjal is good we just don't get enough money. Many a time, we have to sell 20 kg brinjals at Rs 8. Sometimes we don't even get money enough to cover the cost of the sack in which we carry our produce to the market. We don't need Bt seeds. We need cheaper pesticides or some alternative."
Some three dozen farmers were participating in dharna in Ahmedabad to protest the government's attempt to give permission to Bt brinjal.
In New Delhi, Jairam Ramesh had assured that he would take a decision on Bt brinjal in mid-February, and now the farmers are waiting anxiously. Union Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar has already supported the marketing of the Bt brinjal as GEAC has approved it. But the problem is that the credibility of GEAC is under a cloud.
Jatan's Kapil Shah points out: "Some time back GEAC had written to the Gujarat government to destroy the illegal crop of Bt cotton, but no action was taken. How do you expect any better implementation of rules in case of brinjal?"
When rediff.com met some of the farmers in Medhasan village they were scared to talk to the media. Two local farmers who have accepted seeds from Mahyco were afraid to give their names.
They told rediff.com, "It is true that Mahyco has given us brinjal seeds, but we don't know what it contains! We are not sure if its hybrid or Bt brinjal." They avoided all queries related to the subject.
An old farmer in Anandpara village near Modasa said, "When we heard that farmers of Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Maharashtra have accepted illegal Bt brinjal seeds, we too thought of trying it. We are waiting to see the development."
According to his neighbour, they had informed the villagers that they were ready to develop a 'seed plot' for Mahyco.
A senior government officer, dealing exclusively with farmers in Modasa, says: "What regulation? In matters pertaining to rules and regulations in the agriculture sector, India is like a banana republic. The production of Bt cotton also started illegally in a similar fashion. Even today, it is produced illegally in many places. The agriculture sector is in a complete state of chaos. There is no enforcement of law once you go into the interiors of the country."
Shah says that "India grows brinjal worth more than Rs 200 crore (Rs 2 billion) on around 550,000 hectares of farmland. We should oppose Bt brinjal because it is symbolic. One does not know where the entire issue of GM foods will end. We are shooting in the dark without fully knowing and understanding the side-effects."
And even though the supporters of GM foods have ample arguments to counter the robust opposition to Bt brinjal, Jairam Ramesh's current tour shows that the seed companies who are eyeing big business from India will have to work harder to enter the Indian market.
It seems that the battle for GM foods in India has just begun.