Another ‘white elephant’ GMO
Canada has approved a GMO potato. It could be grown and sold without a GMO label this year.
The GMO potato is engineered not to go brown when cut – a quality only of interest to those who wish to pass off non-freshly prepared potatoes as freshly prepared. Keeping cut non-GMO potatoes in water or sprinkling them with a bit of lemon juice prevents them from going brown.
The GMO potato also has low levels of asparagine, an amino acid that when heated to high temperatures forms acrylamide, a suspected carcinogen.
This is a ‘white elephant’ GMO trait, since there are plenty of non-GMO potatoes with naturally low levels of this same amino acid.
Yet Simplot, the company that developed the GMO potato, perversely chose to genetically engineer a potato from a family – the Russets – with the highest levels of asparagine of all potato varieties tested in a comparative analysis.
Crucially, there is also no market demand for the GMO potato.
Health Canada, CFIA approve genetically engineered potato with reduced browning
The Canadian Press
Herald News, March 22, 2016
Health Canada and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency have approved a genetically engineered potato for sale, said a U.S.-based company on Monday in announcing that its non-browning spuds could be in Canadian supermarkets by Thanksgiving.
J.R. Simplot Company was notified by both agencies in letters dated March 18 that it could sell its potatoes — which purportedly are less likely to bruise or turn brown when cut — to consumers or for livestock consumption.
Simplot, based in Boise, Idaho, says the Innate potato has the same nutritional composition of regular potatoes plus reduced asparagine. This amino acid found in many starchy foods produces acrylamide, suspected to be a human carcinogen. Potatoes naturally produce the chemical when they're cooked at high temperatures above 120 C (250 F).
High levels of acrylamide have been found in french fries, potato chips, cookies, coffee, processed cereals and bread, the Canadian Cancer Society says on its website. Health Canada is studying the levels of acrylamide in the food we eat.
"Our potato cuts acrylamide up to 62 per cent and a future generation will take it up to 90 per cent, making it virtually negligible, which is a really big deal in the potato world," says Doug Cole, director of marketing and communications for Simplot.
The company says it uses biotechnology to remove the browning and bruising traits from a typical potato but does not use foreign genes.
"Consumers throw away about 30 per cent of their potatoes either due to bruising or sprouting, so we've solved the bruising problem," says Cole. "When people cut into an ugly black spot they generally think the potato's spoiled and they discard it."
But the potatoes will not have a label indicating they are genetically engineered, as that's not a Health Canada requirement provided they've been deemed safe for consumption. In the U.S., the Innate packaging includes a website and QR code for consumers to seek more information.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture cleared the first generation of the Innate potato in 2014, with the Food and Drug Administration following about a year ago. It's been sold in the U.S. since last May under the White Russet brand and is available in supermarkets and for food service.
The potatoes could be grown in Canada this season and be in stores by the fall.
Kevin MacIsaac, general manager of United Potato Growers of Canada, believes there will be commercial interest in the Innate potatoes. If peeling potatoes in advance of cooking, they need to be covered in cold water with a little vinegar or lemon juice added to avoid browning.
"That was always the drawback in restaurants and vendor shops. You had to almost cut that potato or peel that potato fresh right before you needed it or it would turn brown. I think that's the real attraction," says MacIsaac, whose organization represents 97 per cent of the potato acreage in this country.
MacIsaac, who grew 600 acres of potatoes for 27 years on the family farm in P.E.I., says he tasted Innate mashed potatoes earlier this year at a growers meeting and pronounced them "quite nice" and similar to conventional potatoes.
A second generation of the potato will be resistant to blight, cutting down on the need to apply pesticides in fields to prevent the disease, the company says. It's been approved by the USDA and FDA in the U.S. and is awaiting Environmental Protection Agency approval. Simplot will submit the Gen 2 potato for Canadian review in the next few months, Cole said.
About a year ago, Health Canada approved a similar non-browning Arctic Apple developed by Summerland, B.C.-based Okanagan Specialty Fruits Inc.