20 million strong farmers' body wants charges of treason brought
The Indian farmers' organisation Bharatiya Kisan Sangh (BKS), which has nearly 20 million members, is demanding action against India's GMO regulators - the GEAC - over their complete inaction in the face of clear evidence of the growing of Roundup Ready soybeans. GM herbicide tolerant (HT) crops are illegal in India.
The BKS also want glyphosate banned.
The regulators told Down to Earth, India's long-established science and environment periodical, that it had never received any complaints about the growing of illegal HT crops. But the article provides clear evidence that this is untrue, which includes copies of documents - not reproduced below, but available via the link to the original article.
Down to Earth comments that the inaction of the GEAC shows "this regulatory body is [a] shambles".
The GEAC has long been criticised for acting more like a promoter than a regulator of GM crops.
Illegal GM Soybean: Farmers' body demands CBI probe into GEAC inaction
The biosafety regulatory body denies receiving any complaint about illegal cultivation of GM soybean in some parts of Gujarat
After inaction over four months on complaint of growing illegal genetically modified (GM) soybean in Gujarat, farmer organisation, Bharatiya Kisan Sangh (BKS) demands CBI probe against biosafety regulatory body Genetic Engineering Appraisal Committee (GEAC) along with a case of treason against officials. It also demanded ban on glyphosate — herbicide sprayed on GM crops. BKS claims that it is carcinogenic.
Meanwhile, GEAC has denied receiving any complaint by farmers or civil society body. "We have not received any complaint regarding growing and testing report of HT (Herbicide Tolerant) soya in Gujarat," says Sujata Arora, adviser on biosafety to Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) to Down To Earth.
The GM crops are not considered safe to grow because of gene manipulation. The inaction of GEAC, which is responsible for regulating introduction or growth of GM crops in country, shows how this regulatory body is in shambles.
There is evidence to confirm that BKS had collected illegally cultivated soya samples for lab testing and the report, which turned out to be positive, was sent to the GEAC along with a letter of complaint.
[The original article includes a copy of a test report sent to the GEAC]
Civil society organisation also brought to GEAC’s notice the issue of illegal import of GM soya into the country. "Instead of taking any action, GEAC is just directing Director General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) to check import," says Kavita Kurunganti of ASHA, a Hyderabad based non-profit.
The direction was issued in February 2018, four months after the complaint was made. "The letter was written on February 23, only after an RTI was filed to know about the action taken based on the complaint made in October," says Kurungati.
[The original article includes a copy of the letter to the GEAC, dated 20 October 2017]
In October 2017, Gujarat government had also detected HT soybean crops and registered police complaint against seed sellers and farmers too. It has been said that HT soya seeds have been illegally supplied to farmers of Gujarat, Maharashtra and Telangana.
Laboratory tests, which were also conducted by the Gujarat government, confirmed that these were indeed GM HT soya, which have not been granted permission for field trials, let alone large-scale cultivation.
"Gujarat government had tested these crops in laboratory and found them to be linked to 'Roundup Ready' technology, which belongs to transnational seed manufacturing giant Monsanto," says Magan Bhai Patel, a Gujarat-based farmer leader of BKS.
It is also understood that apart from BKS, the Gujarat government also alerted the GEAC about illegal cultivation of HT soybean in the state. BKS is an affiliated body of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party government.
"The fact that the GEAC is writing now to the DGFT to take action (on preventing the illegal GM imports), makes it clear that it lacks any real intent to take serious action about the violations of its own regulations," says Kavitha Kuruganti. "It also indicates that it is putting up a show of having done something, before an upcoming Supreme Court hearing on PILs related to GMOs," adds Kurunganti.
"It is clear that our regulators—whether it is the GEAC or DGFT—are jeopardising our health and environment by not discharging their regulatory roles," says Rohit Parakh of India for Safe Food, Mumbai.
Meanwhile, government officials have avoided commenting on this development. Murali Krishna, joint director at the MoEFCC, who issued to letter to DGFT, said he will keep us informed about government's response on this issue.